Soy Milk: The Benefits vs. The Dangers

Friday, October 24th, 2008 | Author: Organic Health News

Soy Milk

Soy milk is processed from soy beans through the use of varying manufacturing processes. You can find soy milk with a wide range of fat and protein content, with fat amounts generally ranging from 1-3%. In spite of the tremendous amount of positive press that soy in general seems to receive these days, there is some cause for concern among consumers, particularly when it comes to the consumption of soy milk.

During the past few years, the benefits of soy milk and soy foods have become widely debated. All it takes is a search online to discover some intelligent arguments and clinical studies concerning the potential health dangers that are present in the soy products that American families regularly consume.

While we certainly do not want to label ALL soy products as harmful or dangerous, it is only fair to present you with some essential data representing both sides of this discussion.

The Benefits of Soy Milk


Soy Milk is considered to be a nutritious alternative to cow’s milk for many reasons. First and foremost, soy milk is 100% Lactose-Free, meaning it is a great alternative to those whom suffer from lactose intolerance.

Soy milk may also provide you with beneficial protein, calcium and essential fatty acids, which we all need to live a healthy lifestyle. Soy milk is also low in saturated fat and sodium, but high in dietary fiber.

A recent study from the National Institute of Health & Nutrition in Japan, concludes that soy protein is effective at lowering your cholesterol, which ultimately lowers your overall risk of developing heart-related issues.

Another benefit of soy milk, is the fact that it does not contain a protein called casein, unlike cow’s milk. Casein is commonly used in many different products, ranging from medicine, foods, paints, and adhesives. It is not uncommon for people to develop an allergy to casein. Parents of autistic children need to be aware of products and foods containing casein, as it is widely believed that it can contribute to gastrointestinal disorders.

The Dangers of Soy Milk

Do the benefits of soy milk sound too good to be true? Well, recent research does indicate a few downsides to the consumption of soy foods.

Soy Milk Dangers

Unfermented soy foods have a high amount of phytic acid, which can lead to the lower absorption of certain vitamins and minerals.

Soy contains a high level of phytoestrogen, which may affect the production of sperm in men, as well as decrease the amount of testoterone in their body. The isoflavones found in soy foods also contribute to the development of thyroid disorders, breast cancer and leukemia.

Another less thought of danger, is whether or not the soy you consume is organic. If possible, you should always avoid all genetically modified foods.

The Soy Isoflavone Controversy


Soy isoflavones, also known as phytoestrogens, are routinely marketed as treatments or prevention of certain types of cancer, including prostate, breast, and edometrium.

Part of the problem with the majority of the information that Americans are receiving is that the facts have been somewhat skewed.

For example, some reports have indicated that Asian diets are heavy in soy products, and that these soy-rich diets have resulted in reduced instances of cancers. This is misleading. Asian diets are actually quite low in soy consumption, with diets incorporating healthy amounts of poultry, eggs, fish, and meats.

The amounts of soy that are being placed in foods that Americans eat are exceeding the amounts that Asians consume in an entire day or week. The danger here is that excessive consumption of soy milk, or any other soy product, can lead to the development of many different diseases. For people who have chosen to focus on eating diets that are rich in soy-based products, this presents a very real problem. Unfortunately, many people are not aware that consuming too much soy can be hazardous to their health.

Soy Research & Product Labels

If you are a person who enjoys soy products, and you have incorporated them into your regular diet, you should understand the importance of reading product labels. It is important that you do this not only for those foods that claim to contain soy, but also on all of the food products that you buy. The reason for this is that there are many foods that contain some form of soy. The only way to be sure about this, however, is to read your labels!

The best advice is to research the types of food you eat so that you can make educated decisions about whether or not they are good for you and your family. Try to stick to organic, unprocessed foods as much as possible, and always be aware of the ingredients you are consuming. Genetically Modified Foods are something that you need to steer clear of when at all possible, and unfortunately soy is a primary component in many of these types of food products.

A healthy, lactose-free alternative to soy milk, is hemp milk.

Related Articles About Soy:

Flickr images created by: paPisc & Morgan Tepsic.

Trackback: Trackback-URL | Comments Feed: RSS 2.0
Category: Healthy Living, Natural Diet, Organic Health

You can leave a response.

31 Responses

  1. I love soy milk!

  2. Kind of a fluff piece. I don’t see many citations of studies or statistics. Just casually throws out there “Asian diets are actually quite low in soy consumption, with diets incorporating healthy amounts of poultry, eggs, fish, and meats.” Could you please let us know your sources.

  3. Thanks for interesting information. I think that soy food and soy milk has a good influence on our health. But there is one condition, we shouldn’t over-eat and over-drink this food, so everything must be in balance.

  4. Moderation…just like any other thing in life. Pretty interesting article though.

  5. My girlfriend just recently tried switched to being a vegan and had some soy milk in her fridge. It really wasn’t too bad, but I will show her this article.

    The hemp milk really interests me, I can’t wait to try it.

  6. i personally can’t stand the taste of soy milk. I’d recommend everybody drink ALMOND milk, instead. it’s better for you than soy or cow’s milk, and the taste is waaaaay better!

  7. Do you want to know the #1 Danger of Soy? THE TASTE!!!

  8. Another alternative is rice milk, which is usually more affordable than hemp milk or almond milk.

    I think the real danger in soy is that it’s used as an additive or filler for so many processed foods. I’ve heard that a McDonald’s burger is more soy than meat. The key in a healthy diet is moderation, and it’s hard to do that with a product like soy that is added to so many things.

    I’m far more worried about the dangers in meat and other animal products than the dangers of soy.

  9. Well,this is very upsetting news to me as I LOVE soy milk (the Silk green carton is my favourite, free of all flavourings). However, I am not going to be stopping consumption at this time. I agree with Megan, I too am far more worried about the contents of all the other ‘foods’ presented to us.

  10. I do agree that soy milk can have risks, but only if you drink an abundant amount. Like all things, you should consume in moderation.

    great article. Very informative… thanks for posting it!

  11. I’ve always been curious about the dangers of soy milk.

    I’ve heard two different sides when it comes to soy foods. I don’t believe that eating it in abundance is really even a necessaity. There are other sources for protein, and if soy does propose even the smallest health danger, then we should eat with caution.

    Either way… the taste of hemp milk is better than soy milk. With plenty of health benefits, and no health dangers… Just drink that instead.

  12. I like it… despite the supposed dangers of soy milk, I like the taste and the way I feel after I drink it.

    It’s not wise to eat any soy foods if you suffer from hyperthyroidism.

  13. i also love soy milk, so much healthy and contains lots of nutrient!

    Check out my blogspot
    Cindy

  14. Thanks to a loving dad I realized that giving soy milk to my baby is a BAD thing and I will never do it again hemp milk is the best anyway it contains more nutrients than any other source of anything on our planet… Please do your research…For a healthier you and a healthier planet…. peace, love and naps….

  15. 15
    maria keating 
    Tuesday, 18. November 2008

    My 12 year old son has been diagnosed with leukemia during our time in Japan April 2007. He is still getting chemotheraphy until now and also he had found this web site and told me that “Mom, my Japanese teacher always brings me fresh boiled soy beans to school, maybe that’s how I got my leukemia!” Ever since I read this site I am avoiding to buy soy products due to the risk of this being true.

  16. Hi, within the last two years I have had two major breast cancer operations and am currently on arimidex. I had concerns over any dairy products because of my type of cancer was sensitive to oestrogen. Having taken soya milk for a year I now have been advised by my oncologist that it is equally as harmful because of the phytoestrogens (from plants in this case) which soya contains. I am totally confused. Can anyone shed light on this dilemma.
    Many thanks and good luck Deedy

  17. hola vero aqui el articulo

  18. I found the Michael Pollan book, In Defense of Food, to be extremely enlightening about food choices, production and health consequences including the use of soy in human and animal food. I highly recommend reading it!

  19. I was drinking soy milk everyday for a number of yrs. I stopped drinking it in Oct. of 08. I was told by a health nutritionist that Americans are getting too much soy in their diet. I said: But soy is suppose to be so good for you. She explained that almost everything has soy fillers in it, so therefor we are getting way too much. The reason why I stopped was personal. I was having menstrual problems and as soon as i stopped drinking soy milk my problem stopped and now i have other issues do to soy. So those of you who LOVE SOY. Beware!!! There’s always a price to pay on having too much of a “good thing” Take Caution and Care…

  20. I’ve been taaking too much soy milk lately and this just got me paranoid but fortunately i havent noticed any abnormalities so yeah i’m gonna stop.thanks for the advice or better still warning.

  21. I am a Fitness Model and Actor and have been taking Soy Milk for about 4 years. I have not felt or experienced any symptons or side effects of consuming soy which I consume in large quantities (oatmeal and protein shakes) but lately I have been reading like this about the dangers of soy so I will take a 2-3 month break to see if I feel a difference. Thanks for the information

  22. I was drinking soy milk for several months and did’nt realize what was happening to me and I have even read in years past about dangers from to much soy…I was incredibly cold and was turning my thermostat up more and more and spent a lot of time wrapped up in blankets and extra clothes..my hands and feet would be numb from cold as well as an overall feeling of being cold.. It suddenly dawned on me that it might be the soy , so I stopped .( I recently read that being cold is one of the symptoms , I think especially in men read about it in a letter sent to Obama on the WEESTON PRICE WEBSITE). Within days I returned to my normal self.. dropping the thermostat from as high as 75 degrees to 64-66 degrees.. Iwas’nt eating any tofu during that time and 98% of my diet is organic vegetables and meat….good article and responses

  23. Have there been any limits set with regards to safe amounts of soy milk / soy protein for men? I would be interested in reading some of the latest research. Thank you.

  24. 24
    Vivienne 
    Wednesday, 1. April 2009

    The flavours of soy milk have improved lately, and judging by the numbers of boxes taken off the supermarket shelves, consumption is increasing. With the disposal of bobby calves and the inherent cruelty of the dairy industry, more people should be embrasing soy products instead of dairy.

  25. I’m having a very hard time accepting this report for several reasons. First, you say that the Asian diet contains very little soy consumption. Now even if this is true, the soy consumption in the diet of Asian people as a whole still FAR outweighs that of the western world - and still they have far fewer instances of cancers and other diseases. Also, you speak about diets incorporating healthy amounts of poultry, eggs, fish, and meats. What, exactly, constitutes a healthy amount? EVERY study dealing with cancers and gastrointestinal disorders always suggest much less meat consumption and much more consumption of vegetables, fruits, and grains. And the benefits of soy have been well researched and are very well documented. Mankind is the ONLY species who continues to drink milk into adulthood - to to add to that drinks the milk of another species. And if eating meat was all that natural then man would be able to consume it raw like all the other natural meat eaters. Of course there must be balance in everything. I agree with you that one should be sure that the soy you consume is organic. That’s the key. But soy products have been shown in many studies to be an excellent alternative for people who have been suffering from many ailments due to the consumption of meat and dairy products.

  26. 26
    OutdoorEd 
    Monday, 27. April 2009

    I’ve had a soy-milk fruit smoothie every morning for the past two years and been feeling amazing. Recent reports of the dangers of soy have given me pause. I’m reading The Okinawa Program now, which studies the lifestyle and diet of the Okinawan elders and youth. There are more centenarians per capita on this island than anywhere else in the world however the Western diet is starting to influence trends with today’s generation, providing insight into intergenerational trends based on food intake. Great book with insights into a healthy Asian diet.

    http://www.okinawaprogram.com/books/okinawa_program.html

  27. I’ve recently started drinking soy milk, hoping that it will some way help my with my endomitriose and gastro problems. I have been feeling better, by being more regular and reduced pain associated with the endometriosis. After reading this article with i found very interesting, i am now more confused that ever, if I’m actually benefiting from drinking soy milk or not.

  28. I’m 19 years old, and lactose intolerant. I have grown up drinking soy milk all my life, even for baby formula since I cannot take cow’s milk. I can’t even drink non-lactaid cow’s milk. I am perfectly healthy, my doctors have never found anything wrong with me, besides the occasional cold and such. My normal food intake consists of fish, turkey, chicken, grains, fruit, veggies, and pork & beef on occasions. Junk food on weekends.Maybe the bad side effects of soy milk depends on the person, and what the person eats.

  29. This article is good but hs no foundation, nor proof of their claims. I have been using soy milk for years, because I’m lactose into relent. You notice the author tells you to pick hemp. I’m sure he is being payed to push that.

  30. I love chocolate soy milk…tastes like Yoo Hoo!

  31. When I was a kid attending elementary school in Hong Kong I used to drink a 7oz bottle of soy milk for lunch EVERYDAY. The reason is that flash milk was expensive in HK and we thus drank a lot of soy milk instead.

    I never had any health problem because of that.

Leave a Reply

*
To prove that you're not a bot, enter the code you see below
Anti-Spam Image